Asia Credit Advisors
  • Home
  • Profile
  • Investment Blog
  • Events and Press
    • Events
    • Press Articles
    • Media Quotes
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer

Who is responsible for India's slowdown?

6/6/2013

5 Comments

 
India’s economic growth has slid inexorably from a height of 9.4% in the Jan-Mar 2010 quarter to a low of 4.8% in the latest quarter. Although India’s prime minister fervently argues that it is just a cyclical slowdown and will reverse soon, there are many structural factors too behind the fading of growth.

I was surprised to read the recent article by Raghuram Rajan on India’s slowing. In his piece, he identifies two reasons: one, he says India’s economic institutions were not ready to support a high growth, and two, he points to global financial crisis. But in both cases, he argues that the political system stepped in to save the poor and the weak against institutional failures and against unbridled development; and the political reaction led to the fall deceleration.

It is indeed a strange take on the recent issues in India. The first question to ask is this: if indeed the economic institutions failed the people, who created those economic institutions? It is the politicians! The political class has been far from being the saviors of the poor, weak, oppressed, swindled and the trampled masses; indeed, it is the political class that has been doing the oppressing, the trampling and the swindling of the people.

I am not sure why Rajan argues this way, but I hope that he has not become a part of the “system” after serving as the chief economic advisor to the government. I also hope the possibility of his nomination as the next governor of the Reserve Bank of India has nothing to do with this line of argument.

Unsustainable structure

Why, then, did Indian growth decline back to the disappointing “Hindu rate of growth”? There are many structural imbalances in the economy that have impeded India’s potential to achieve high growth rates. To start with is the persistent fiscal deficit (4.9% of GDP for 2012-13), which can be traced not only to the traditional food, fuel and fertilizer subsidies, but also to the newer employment guarantee programs started by the current Congress government. 

The high fiscal deficit also leaves little money for infrastructure investment or development expenditure. India’s power sector, for example, has perpetually run at a deficit of 7-10% and suffered a power blackout in July 2012 that left 620 million people or half of the country’s population without power! In the southern state of Tamil Nadu, for example, my mother still suffers from power cuts of 2 hours when she is in the state capital of Chennai, and 10
hours when she travels to the other cities in the state.

India’s  current-account deficit has soared in the last five years from 1% to 4% of GDP,  thanks to global oil prices and Indians’ insatiable lust for buying gold. (In fact, the deficit hit 6.7% of GDP for the Oct-Dec 2012 quarter.) At the same time, exports have faced headwinds from the economic slackening in the U.S. and Europe. Besides, barring a few companies, Indian manufacturers have not risen to the challenge of building themselves into sustainable exporters in terms of scale, technology and cost-competitiveness. 

India’s balance of payments has always been dependent on foreign capital inflows (except for a couple of years in the mid-2000s when the current account moved close to break-even), but the recent widening of the current account has made the task of attracting foreign capital  even more critical. 

Confidence

Investment, both domestic and foreign, depends ultimately on confidence. After all, investors are trusting that their money would come back to them with a reasonable return. Indian politicians have singularly failed to create and sustain confidence in the economy.

For many years, the Congress-led coalition has governed the country without instituting any meaningful structural reforms. Even the few initiatives that it tried to advance, such as the nuclear agreement with the U.S. and opening up of the multi-brand retail sector, faced considerable headwinds in the political system. Congress’s allies also put up a price for their support on every single issue. Although now postponed to 2016, India’s attempt to change the taxation principles for foreign investors investing though third countries such as Mauritiusalso produced considerable uncertainty for investors.

Corruption has played a big role in turning off investors. Instead of positive reforms, corruption scandals emerged with regularity. Who would want to invest in the telecom sector if they faced the prospect of the licenses being cancelled? Coalgate (as the coal-sector scandal is popularly called) managed to slow investments in the coal sector. Before that, the 2G telecom licensing scandal led to the mass cancellation of licenses, leading to the withdrawal of some international telecom companies.

It is clear that India is fighting the fire with some measures to control the fiscal deficit, retain the investment-grade credit ratings, ease the flow of investments into infrastructure, and revive the economic growth. It is the long-established pattern again: India will act only after facing the crisis.

Who is responsible for this mess? Rajan may feel that the political process is the necessary corrective factor against unbridled market forces. In reality, it is the political class that has brought the country down.
5 Comments
Sean Chang
18/6/2013 03:59:14 pm

Hi Dilip, that's good writeup, I really want to share some of your research with colleagues and with wider readers among us. Let me know how this could work out. Best Regards, Sean

Reply
Dilip Parameswaran
19/6/2013 02:15:10 pm

Hi Sean, I am glad you liked the blog. To share the blog write-ups, there are many ways:

1. Send them the URL.
2. They could subscribe to the RSS feed in the blog and use an RSS reader like Feedly. Their feeds will get updated every time there is a new blog.
3. Follow me on Twitter. Every time there is a new blog, a twitter goes out automatifcally, so that readers would know there has been a new blog.
4. Cut and paste the article and circulate it.

Cheers
Dilip

Reply
Nirmal Rajani
8/8/2013 12:55:41 pm

Hi Dhilipan, good write up. My point of view is also that corruption is the core issue.

Reply
Balaji Venkatachalam
8/8/2013 03:08:07 pm

Dhileepa, Good one. Behavior of Indian political class is worsening day by day. Look at the Durga Nagapal vs Akhilesh Yadav scenario in UP. Now other governments are following the same as they have also realized that media will shout for few days and some other issue will take over. It is like the citizens and corporates being forced to work with their hands tied. Regards, Balaji

Reply
RR
8/8/2013 10:42:56 pm

Dilip.. great article. If India's savings rate is going down and inspite of that GDP is going down.. isn't it double whammy .. ? Now with the rupeee depreciating, isn't that going to fuel inflation again ?
As you said, neither the nuclear deal nor the FDI relaxation has helped in any way. I guess the fundamental issue is that Brand India has taken a beating under UPA2.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed


    Author

    Dilip Parameswaran
    Twitter: @AsianCredit

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Categories

    All
    Asia
    Asian Hard Currency Bonds
    Asian Hard Currency Bonds
    Bonds
    Books
    China
    Economics
    Equity
    High Yield
    High Yield
    India


    Archives

    September 2019
    January 2019
    May 2018
    January 2017
    September 2016
    May 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013


    Recent  posts

    FeedWind

    Like it? Share it!

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.